Bad: Butch Davis
Credit: Getty Images
College record: 63-43, 5-0 bowl record; NFL record: 24-35 -- Butch Davis had modest success at the University of Miami – at least by “The U” standards. He didn’t win more than nine games until his final season, leading the Hurricanes to an 11-1 record and a Sugar Bowl win. He jumped to the Cleveland Browns, but was fired in the middle of his fourth season. He returned to coaching at North Carolina for four seasons, ending in 2010.