SPOKANE, Wash. -- The state of Washington and the federal government on Friday rejected each other's competiting proposal to amend a federal court agreement governing cleanup of the Hanford Nuclear Reservation, the nation's most polluted nuclear weapons production site.
The state sent a letter to federal lawyers, saying the March 31 proposal from the U.S. Department of Energy that would have eliminated many deadlines for Hanford cleanup "is not acceptable to Washington."
Later in the day, a letter to Washington's Department of Ecology from Justice Department attorneys officially rejected the state's plan to accelerate the Hanford cleanup, saying the state's plan ignored technical realities and pressures on the Energy Department's budget.
Hanford for decades made plutonium for nuclear weapons, and now is engaged in cleaning up the nation's largest volume of radioactive wastes. The site is near Richland.
The cleanup is governed by a federal court consent decree reached in 2010 that sets strict milestones for the cleanup process. But the Energy Department has said it is in danger of missing many of those milestones because of the scientific complexity of the work.
The state has threatened to take the department back to court in an effort to get the decadeslong cleanup back on track. The cleanup costs taxpayers about $2 billion per year.
The state has issued its own proposal to amend the consent decree, but the state plan includes numerous deadlines and requires the completion of all waste treatment by the original deadline of 2047.
A major problem with the cleanup is that construction of a unique facility called the Waste Treatment Plant, which is designed to turn the most dangerous wastes into glasslike logs for eventual burial, has been indefinitely delayed by technical and safety concerns.
"Energy proposes to indefinitely extend most of the consent decree's WTP deadlines by trading current hard deadlines and specific tasks for future unspecified milestones to be set on an open-ended, rolling basis," the state complained in the letter.
The consent decree set deadlines for emptying some of Hanford's underground waste tanks and starting to treat up to 56 million gallons of nuclear waste at the Waste Treatment Plant. But the Energy Department has said most of the remaining deadlines are at risk of being missed, including having the plant fully operational by 2022.
The Energy Department wants to set deadlines only for retrieving some waste from leak-prone tanks and on parts of the Waste Treatment Plant not affected by technical and safety issues.
The department has said setting deadlines that likely will be missed creates false expectations in the community and with the state, and erodes confidence in the cleanup work.
Washington state officials now must decide whether to invoke a dispute resolution clause in the consent decree that would initiate a 40-day process of good faith negotiation. If an agreement is not reached, the state may then ask a federal court to issue an order directing Energy to implement the state’s plan.
KING 5's Russ Walker contributed to this article.